A recent case from the Alberta Court of Appeal demonstrates that
claims in pure economic loss can be difficult and that there needs
to be sufficient directness or relatedness of relationship and
damage for a party to succeed. In addition, individual proceedings,
as opposed to class proceedings, may be more appropriate where
parties have distinct issues to pursue.
Background
In June 2012, a pipeline owned and operated by Plains Midstream
Canada ULC ("Plains") released crude oil into the Red
Deer River, eventually being deposited downstream to Gleniffer Lake
(the "Spill"). The Red Deer River and Gleniffer Lake,
both public bodies of water, were closed for recreational use due
to the Spill. The Riegers, who jointly owned property near-to but
not boarding on Gleniffer Lake, and which they had been attempting
to sell, commenced an action under the Class Proceedings
Act against Plains, alleging that the Spill and related loss
of use of the public bodies of water