On January 16, 2019, Justice Perell of the Ontario
Superior Court of Justice approved a Settlement Agreement in
Hodge v. Neinstein, a complex class action involving novel
questions of law, including whether or not breaches of the Solicitors Act could be pursued by way
of a class action and whether disgorgement of overcharged legal
fees and disbursements was a viable remedy.
Facts
In 2012, the Applicant, Ms. Cassie Hodge commenced a class
proceeding against Gary Neinstein and Neinstein & Associations
LLP seeking repayment of legal fees and disbursements paid by her
and other Class Members upon the settlement of their motor vehicle
personal injury claims. She alleged that the Neinstein firm
breached the Solicitors Act and their fiduciary duties
because they charged an amount for costs, in addition to a
percentage fee pursuant to a contingency fee retainer agreement.
She also alleged that the firm charged excessive disbursements and
interest on those disbursements.