In Cirillo v. Ontario, the Ontario Court
of Appeal upheld the denial of certification of a proposed class
action alleging a systemic failure by the Crown to hold timely bail
hearings for accused persons.
Background
The proposed representative plaintiff, Robin Cirillo, was
arrested in May 2017 following a domestic altercation with her
ex-spouse. Cirillo was detained overnight for a bail hearing. The
hearing was subsequently delayed for various reasons until the
following day, when she was released on consent.
Cirillo sought to certify a class action against the Crown in
negligence, breach of fiduciary duty and breach of various
Charter rights. The proposed class was defined as all
persons who were arrested and detained for a period of more than 24
hours prior to any bail hearing "as a result of" five
specified causes. The claim generally alleged that the Crown
mismanaged the bail system, failed to commit adequate resources and
promoted policies for prosecutors