Where a driver’s speed is the sole alleged basis of
negligence and the driver was travelling at or near the posted
speed limit a conclusion that the driver was driving too fast for
the conditions, in and of itself, is not sufficient to find driver
negligence – a proper “but for” causation
analysis must be undertaken.
Jadhav v Kielly, 2019 NLCA 5, per Welsh
J.A.
Facts + Issues
Jadhav was struck by a motor vehicle driven by Kielly and was
injured. The Trial Judge concluded that Kielly was liable in
negligence, but that Jadhav was 10% at fault in contributory
negligence.
At the time of the accident, it was dark, raining heavily, and
windy. Jadhav was wearing all black and walking along the shoulder
of the road with the flow of traffic. Kielly was driving in the
same direction and struck Jadhav as he walked.