Retail investors who use self-directed online discount
brokerages have limited ability to blame the brokerage for their
own investment decisions. Where an investor suffers a loss from a
poor investment decision, the Court has signalled a willingness to
strictly enforce the terms and conditions of the applicable account
agreement to preclude any claims that the investor may pursue
against the brokerage.
Overview
In a recent decision of the Supreme Court of British
Columbia, Baan v. Scotia Capital Inc., 2023 BCSC 565,
the Court held that the brokerage was not liable for an
investor's decision to sell shares that he did not own in a
junior mining company that had just completed a 10:1 share
consolidation. The Court also held that the brokerage had the
right, under the applicable account agreement, to liquidate the
other securities held in his investment account to partially cover
the resulting shortfall. The Court granted judgment in favour of
the brokerage for the