On October 16, 2018, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice
released a decision in Richardson v. Samsung, denying
certification of a proposed national class action.
The case is about cell phones that were alleged to overheat,
creating a risk of fire or explosion. The manufacturer and Health
Canada issued a recall of the phones. In her decision, Justice
Rady, wrote "this being a product liability case, one might
think it is ideal for certification (para. 2)" but found that
some prerequisites to certification were not met in the
case.
The plaintiff's complaint was that the manufacturer's
compensation package following its recall of the devices was
inadequate, because it did not properly reimburse consumers for
their losses. The Court disagreed.