In the recent decision of Zacon Limited v Provincial Doors
Inc et al, 2025 ONSC 2954 (the "Court's
Decision"), the Ontario Superior Court of Justice
(the "ONSC") found that, under the
Patent Act, RSC 1985, c P-4 (the
"Act"), a re-examination board's
decision on the patentability of a patent "does not
usurp" the court's ability to determine the validity of
the same patent.
Background
In October 2006, Zacon Limited
("Zacon") was issued Canadian Patent No.
2,348,348 entitled "Balanced Ventilation Doors" (the
"'348 Patent"). In 2019, Zacon
initiated a patent infringement action in the ONSC (the
"Action") against, among others,
Provincial Doors Inc. ("Provincial") and
Pretium Resources Inc. ("Pretium"). In
response, Provincial and Pretium both asserted affirmative defences
that the '348 Patent was invalid on the grounds of anticipation
and obviousness (the "Affirmative
Defences").