Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 10 MARCH 2017

A Quarter Million In Punitive Damages Upheld In Chanel Counterfeit Appeal

$314,000 in damages, $66,000 in costs at first instance, plus solicitor-client costs on the appeal (which was found to be "without merit"). In Lam v. Chanel S. de R.L., 2017 FCA 38, the Federal Court of Appeal confirmed these awards for four instances of selling counterfeit CHANEL goods at a Toronto-area mall between 2011 and 2013

CanadaIntellectual Property

$314,000 in damages, $66,000 in costs at first instance, plus solicitor-client costs on the appeal (which was found to be "without merit"). In Lam v. Chanel S. de R.L., 2017 FCA 38, the Federal Court of Appeal confirmed these awards for four instances of selling counterfeit CHANEL goods at a Toronto-area mall between 2011 and 2013. The volume of counterfeits was less than 200 and included items such as cell phone cases, wallets, earrings, plastic bracelets and "fake nail stickers".

This decision represents an apparent close to a four-year saga involving a judgment after summary trial (2015 FC 1091), an appeal and remand back to the Federal Court on a damages issue (2016 FCA 11), and then a further decision by the trial judge (2016 FC 987). At issue on this appeal were the awards of compensatory and punitive damages, and costs. The FCA confirmed the decision below, which itself confirmed the 2015 summary trial decision awarding $64,000 in compensatory damages, plus

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from