RVB Managements Ltd. v. Rocky Mountain
House, 2015 ABCA 304, per Paperny, Watson, Slatter
JJ.A.
I. FACTS AND ISSUES
This was a $25 million tort claim against a municipality. It
culminated in a long, 27-day trial over two years. The Plaintiffs
ended up getting nothing. They appealed and lost. The parties could
not agree on costs. The trial judge made a costs award that 1)
adjusted the costs for inflation and 2) used a column multiplier,
since the amount at issue was several times the $1.5 million Column
5 number.
II. HELD: Inflation adjustments and column multipliers are
permissible
1. Inflation
(a) The current amounts were enacted
in 1998 and haven't been changed. Some trial judges have
allowed indexing for inflation; some haven't. There has been no
direct appellate ruling on the issue.