Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 14 MARCH 2016

Costs Per Schedule C Can Be Increased For Inflation And Subjected To A Multiplier For Complexity Of The Case

This was a $25 million tort claim against a municipality.

CanadaInsurance

RVB Managements Ltd. v. Rocky Mountain House, 2015 ABCA 304, per Paperny, Watson, Slatter JJ.A.

I. FACTS AND ISSUES

This was a $25 million tort claim against a municipality. It culminated in a long, 27-day trial over two years. The Plaintiffs ended up getting nothing. They appealed and lost. The parties could not agree on costs. The trial judge made a costs award that 1) adjusted the costs for inflation and 2) used a column multiplier, since the amount at issue was several times the $1.5 million Column 5 number.

II. HELD: Inflation adjustments and column multipliers are permissible

1. Inflation

(a) The current amounts were enacted in 1998 and haven't been changed. Some trial judges have allowed indexing for inflation; some haven't. There has been no direct appellate ruling on the issue.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from