On July 11, 2014, the Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC")
issued its decision in Grassy Narrows First Nation v Ontario, 2014
SCC 48 ("Keewatin") and confirmed that
Ontario has the exclusive power to "take up" treaty lands
located in the Keewatin area of Treaty 3 within Ontario for
development purposes.
The Keewatin decision is significant because this
historical treaty is one of 11 historical numbered treaties across
Canada that were instrumental in securing title and opening up the
country for settlement. Several of these historical numbered
treaties contain similar terms in respect to the Crown's
ability to take up lands for development.
In those circumstances where the beneficial interest in the
affected treaty lands is held by the province, the SCC has
confirmed that the province will have the power to take up the
lands and regulate the resources associated with such lands,
subject to the duty to consult and accommodate, if appropriate,
with the Aboriginal group.