One of the key elements in most tender and RFP processes, is a
requirement for tenders or proposals to be submitted by a certain
time. In many cases, this is a mandatory requirement, so that bids
which are received after the stated time are invalid, with little
or no discretion for the owner to accept the late bids. Not
surprisingly, this has given rise to a variety of cases determining
exactly what the relevant time is.
The first of these is Smith Bros. and Wilson (BC) Ltd.
v. BC Hydro and Power Authority. In this case the relevant
time was described in two separate places in the documents as
"until 11:00 a.m." and "not later than 11:00
a.m.". The judge held that these words did not allow tenders
to be delivered until 11:01 a.m. The closing time was exactly 11:00
a.m. In contrast, the Ontario Court of Appeal held in Bradscott
(MCL) Ltd. v. Hamilton-Wentworth Catholic District School
Board that a closing time of "at 1:00 p.m." allowed
tenders to be delivered at any