So far this blog has been largely focussed on a contractual
analysis of the procurement process - the Contract A/Contract B
analysis and the degree to which terms can be implied into Contract
A.
Metercor Case
The 2011 BC case of Metercor Inc. v. Kamloops
shows a different way for a disgruntled bidder to challenge a
procurement decision that has gone against them. In this case, the
City of Kamloops issued a request for proposals for the
installation of water meters. The unsuccessful proponent (CMI)
brought an action for judicial review of the City's decision to
enter into negotiations with the successful proponent
(Neptune).
The RFP set out a two-stage evaluation process. Proposals were
first scored for their technical merits and only those proposals
that scored at least 75% on this basis (56.25 marks) went on to be
assessed on the basis of price. Neptune was the only proponent who
scored over 75% and was therefore the only proponent whose price
was considered