The Background
In late-December 2008, the Supreme Court of Canada (the
"Court" or the
"SCC") released the written reasons for
its decision earlier in the year to approve the plan of arrangement
by which the proposed acquisition of BCE Inc.
("BCE") was to proceed. For reasons
unrelated to the issues that the Court had considered at the
hearing of this matter in June, 2008 the proposed acquisition had
been terminated just prior to the release of the SCC's
reasons.
The reasons set out a flexible blueprint that may help to guide
directors in their decision-making process in the context of change
of control transactions. Although the Court's decision does not
provide boards of directors and their advisors with a clear roadmap
to this decision-making or as to the discharge of their fiduciary
obligations, its strong affirmation of the "business judgment
rule" – the principle that courts should generally
defer to, and not second-guess, the reasonable business judgment