2011 SCC 12 (Released March 4, 2011)
Charter of Rights and Freedoms – Equality Rights
– Age Discrimination – Use of Comparator
Groups
The appellants, who were representative plaintiffs in a class
action against the Crown, were widows whose federal supplementary
death benefits were reduced because of their husbands' ages.
The appellants submitted that the age-based benefit reduction,
which was part of a statutory death benefit scheme for certain
federal government employees, violated section 15 of the
Charter.
While the Supreme Court of Canada ultimately dismissed the
widows' appeal, it rejected the Crown's argument that
because their husbands were the actual subjects of the alleged
discrimination, the widows lacked standing. The court granted the
widows standing on the basis that as surviving spouses they
suffered the alleged discriminatory effect. Furthermore, federal
employees were unlikely to challenge the scheme of their own
accord.