Introduction
The interrelated contracts principle continues to gain momentum
in Canadian contract law. Simply put, the courts favour an
interpretive approach that looks beyond the four corners of a
single contract and will often consider a series of contracts to
give effect to a transaction; all of the contracts in a series of
contracts must be considered in interpreting any one of them. The
recent Ontario Court of Appeal decision of Downey v. Ecore
International Inc., contains a strong reaffirmation that the
privity of contract principle erodes when interrelated contracts
are at play.
The facts
Paul Downey, an engineer, was lured away by a competitor of his
previous employer to work at the competitor's Pennsylvania
based manufacturing company (Ecore International Inc.). For tax
purposes, Mr. Downey wanted his employment relationship to be
structured as a consulting agreement with his own company, CSR
Industries ("CSR"), rather than the