Bill S-201,An Act to prohibit and prevent genetic
discrimination, is currently being reviewed and debated by
the Senate Standing Committee on Human Rights. If passed, this Bill
would impose quasi-criminal sanctions for genetic discrimination in
the workplace, meaning that employers could face significant
penalties in the future, including imprisonment. While the
principle behind this Bill is commendable, two problematic issues
should be considered.
First, the Bill provides for a multiplicity of proceedings by
which an employee can seek both quasi-criminal recourse under the
Genetic Non-Discrimination Act, and civil recourse under
the current Canada Labour Code or the Canadian Human
Right Act. Such a wide array of legal avenues is worrisome, as
it may inadvertently undermine judicial efficiency and promote
duplicate litigation against employers. It should be noted that the
Supreme Court of Canada, in British Columbia v Malik, recently
cautioned against practices that