A recent majority decision by the Alberta Court of Appeal,
City Wide Towing and Recovery Service Ltd. v. Poole, 2020
ABCA 305, revisits whether a court can sever or restrict
overly-broad provisions within restrictive covenants (known as
“notional” and “blue-pencil” severance).
This case also holds that the doctrine of severance has broader
application in the commercial setting than the employment
setting.
At issue in this case was the enforceability of a
non-competition clause agreed to by Devon Poole as part of the sale
of his business, Capital Towing
(“Capital”), to City Wide Towing and
Recovery Service Ltd. (“City Wide”).
After the sale closed, Poole resigned from City Wide's employ
and began employment with DRM Recovery Ltd.
(“DRM”), an alleged competitor of City
Wide. This prompted City Wide to bring an action and application
for injunction against Poole and DRM for breach of the restrictions
in the commercial agreement that Poole entered into as part of