In Canada, restrictive covenants in employment agreements can be
very difficult to enforce, particularly by way of injunctive
relief. This is often because employers are unable to demonstrate
that there is:
- a serious issue to be tried
(typically because the covenant is too long in duration or poorly
drafted, making it either ambiguous or overly broad and
unreasonable); or
- irreparable harm that would occur to
the employer if an injunction were not granted.
In a recent decision1, the Superior Court of Justice
in Ontario issued Stress-Crete Limited and Luminaire Company Inc.
(collectively "StressCrete"), family-run businesses who
manufacture and supply lighting solutions internationally, an
injunction enforcing the non-solicitation covenant signed by its
former employee Mr. Harriman. Mr. Harriman was
StressCrete's Sales Manager of U.S. Northeast and Canada, until
he resigned from StressCrete to join Cyclone, a direct competitor.
Mr. Harriman had signed both a