In Passamaquoddy Lodge v CUPE Local 1763 2016 NBQB 056
the Court of Queen's Bench upheld an original arbitration
decision condemning an employer for suspending an employee pending
the outcome of a psychiatric evaluation.
The Facts
Mr. Lister worked in the maintenance department at a nursing
home in St. Andrews, New Brunswick and was represented by CUPE,
Local 1763. The employer had become concerned for Mr. Lister's
mental stability, contending he was acting "erratic" and
"non-predictable". The grievor also had a history of
"causing trouble" for the employer and was the object of
a police investigation for a non-work related incident.
In February 2012, Mr. Lister raised concerns with his employer
and alleged the presence of asbestos on pipes in the nursing home.
The Lodge brought in environmental consultants, but Mr. Lister
questioned their qualifications and made statements challenging the
accuracy of the expert advice they provided as to health and
safety.