Settlements with regulatory bodies regarding infractions are
generally final and binding on all of the parties. This allows the
parties to put the regulatory infraction to rest and move forward
with their lives. But what happens when a decision of today calls
into question the fairness of a settlement from yesteryear? That is
the question at the heart of the Ontario Securities Commission
(OSC) decision issued in the matter of Marc McQuillen on September
15, 2014.
Mr. McQuillen worked as an Assistant to Mr. David Berry when Mr.
Berry was head of preferred share trading at Scotia Capital. Both
were charged by Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of
Canada (IIROC), a self-regulatory organization (SRO) under purview
of the OSC, with manipulating the sale of new share issues being
underwritten by Scotia. Mr. McQuillen settled with IIROC and paid a
$25,000 fine in lieu of undergoing costly proceedings. Mr. Berry
did not settle, but years later won his case against