Almost 20 years on from the High Court's consideration of
the entitlement to claim damages for 'wrongful birth' in
Cattanach v Melchior 1 (Cattanach), this article
revisits some aspects of damages assessment, primarily in respect
of the costs of raising and maintaining a child.
The special leave question before the High Court in Cattanach
was limited to the issue of damages for raising and maintaining the
child. The Court did not address the other two aspects of the claim
that had been considered by the primary judge, namely the
mother's claim for damages relating to the pregnancy and birth,
and the father's damages for loss of consortium 2
(the latter available in Queensland but removed by statute in some
other Australian jurisdictions).