If you have acted as an expert witness, you will know one of the
most fundamental rules is that you must be impartial and not act as
an advocate. This is codified in expert witness codes of conduct
throughout Australia and is an established precedent in decided
court cases. Despite this, experts regularly act as an advocate for
the party which retained them, placing their reputation and future
work at risk. In this bulletin, we will explore a few ways experts
can end up acting as advocates and suggest ways to avoid this.
The Rule
The rule that an expert is not, and must not become, an advocate
for a party is contained in expert witness codes of conduct in all
Australian jurisdictions. Underpinning this rule is the principle
that an expert witness is engaged to provide impartial assistance,
so the court or tribunal will have the necessary evidence in the
area of specialised knowledge and the claim can be properly
decided.