The recent Federal Court decision in Australian
Competition and Consumer Commission v Trivago NV (No 2) (ACCC
v Trivago) has confirmed courts will not shy away from ordering
large civil penalties, where appropriate.
The Court was required to consider whether an appropriate marker
of 'benefit' – a well-established penalty factor in
civil penalty proceedings – was revenue or profit. Noting
that both are relevant, the Court confirmed that it is not limited
to a consideration of profit. Instead, it is able to (and should)
look to the (often much larger) measure of revenue.
A refresher - how are civil penalties calculated?
In addition to setting out a framework to establish the maximum
penalty, legislation often refers to the imposition of a pecuniary
penalty that the Court considers is
'appropriate'.1 The primary driver of
appropriateness is general and specific deterrence; and promoting
the public interest in compliance.2 Penalties must be of
such a magnitude so as