Mastronardi Produce Ltd v The Registrar of Trade
Marks [2014] FC 1021
KEY ISSUE
Use of product variety names as a trade mark – inherent
distinctiveness
FACTS
M applied to register ZIMA as a brand name for tomatoes in class
31.
The Registrar refused the application: it was not inherently
adapted to distinguish (section 41(6), being descriptive of a type
of tomato and that its registration would be likely to deceive or
cause confusion (section 43) if M used the mark other than for the
type of tomato with which consumers associated the name.
M appealed to the Federal Court.
COURT DECISION AND REASONING
The 2 stage test proposed by Kitto J in Clarke Equipment case in
1964 applies to inherent distinctiveness (reasonably consistent
with the decision of the High Court in the Cantarella Bros case
above):