Introduction
The decision of Greenwood J in Mayne Industries Pty Ltd v
Advanced Engineering Group Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 27 was delivered
on 23 January 2008 (the "Judgment").
The Judgment considers whether:
- the Respondent infringed a trade mark comprising a sign
being a three-dimensional shape (an S loop);
- the features of the shape bear any relation to the
function to be performed by the loop or the nature of the
goods; and
- the importation of articles embodying the shape for sale
and distribution and promotion through the use of advertising
brochures is use of the trade mark, as a trade mark.
The Judgment illustrates that the Trademarks Act 1995 (Cth)
(the "Act") cannot be relied on to provide enduring
exclusive rights to protect an article previously protected
under a patent. The Judgment suggests that the Act is
particularly unreliable in providing exclusive