Copyright/Design Overlap: Yacht plugs as works of artistic
craftsmanship?
Burge v Swarbrick [2007] HCA 17
Mr Swarbrick has designed numerous yachts including a 30
foot sports boat marketed as the “JS 9000”
in Australia.
Boldgold Investments manufactured competitive boats to the
JS 9000 using the hull and deck mouldings developed for the JS
9000. These mouldings had been obtained (in disputed
circumstances) by two former employees of Mr Swarbrick and
applied in the competitive Boldgold business.
Mr Swarbrick had not registered the design of the mouldings
or the plug used to create the mouldings under the Designs Act
1906. He asserted that the design for the plug and the
mouldings were “works of artistic
craftsmanship” and therefore protected under
Australian copyright law. If Mr Swarbrick’s argument
failed, he would have no protection due to the provisions in
the Copyright Act 1968