Judgment date: 11 May 2012
Kelly McCann v NSW Self Insurance Group [2012]
NSWSC 488
Supreme Court of New South Wales1
In Brief
Where its provisions are open to interpretation a structured
settlement will be interpreted in favour of the injured
claimant.
Background
The claimant was an infant female who was catastrophically
injured in a motor accident on 13 September 1985. As a result of
her injuries she required constant intensive care. The claim was
resolved in 1986 with a structured settlement which provided for an
upfront lump sum payment and ongoing payment of medical expenses,
attendant care services and equipment.
A dispute arose in 2011 regarding the extent of care that was
required, partly because the claimant had a child. This dispute was
resolved between the parties and a further deed was entered in
2011. A further dispute arose regarding the provision of care,
particularly in relation to whether the insurer was obliged to pay
for nursing