The majority of the High Court
ruled on Wednesday that the indefinite detention of refugees,
asylum seekers and long-term residents who are found to be unlawful
noncitizens can lawfully be held in immigration detention for an
indefinite period of time under authority of the executive.
Four High Court Justices – Susan Kiefel, Stephen Gageler,
Patrick Keane and Simon Steward – upheld an appeal brought by
the federal government against a September 2020 Federal Court
ruling –
known as AJL20 – which found that constitutional limits
don't permit the executive to do this.
The case put by
human rights lawyer Alison Battisson in AJL20 involved the
ongoing detention of a then
29-year-old Syrian man, following the cancellation of his visa
in 2014 on character grounds. Having migrated in 1996, the
government hadn't deported him due to non-refoulement
obligations.