Almost 17 years after the High Court handed down its seminal
judgment in Hollis v Vabu1, the debate
regarding the distinction between contractor and employee
continues. This time, however, the debate has taken the form of a
Federal Court of Australia class action in Bywater v Appco
Group Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 707.
In discussing Bywater, this article looks at class
actions as a mechanism for workers to collectively pursue employers
for underpayment, sham contracting and other breaches of the
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the effect such a phenomenon
may have if it takes off.
Background
For a period of about two years, Jacob Bywater engaged in
marketing and selling merchandise to the public on behalf of
various charities and organisations. Mr Bywater provided these
services pursuant to an agreement he entered with Onshore Sports
Group Pty Limited and, later, Bay Marketing Group Pty Limited. Both
agreements provided that Mr Bywater was engaged as an
"Independent