Court of Appeals Weighs in on Tax Assessment
Property taxes often represent a significant chunk of an
owner's annual expenses. Even when tax bills are high, many
taxpayers simply accept the billed amounts calculated by their
assessors.
That might not be wise, as a recent case in California
illustrates. In SHC Half Moon Bay, Inc. v. County of San Mateo
(Cal. App. 2014), the California Court of Appeals, applying
property tax laws similar to those in some other jurisdictions,
found that a county's assessment improperly inflated a
hotel's value — in turn improperly inflating the
hotel's property taxes.
Hotel Owner Challenges Property Tax
In 2004, SHC Half Moon Bay purchased the Ritz-Carlton Half Moon
Bay Hotel for about $124 million. The purchase price included real
and personal property (furniture, fixtures and equipment), as well
as intangible assets and rights. As part of an income valuation
approach, the San Mateo County assessor assessed the hotel at