At this time last year, employers with pre-dispute arbitration agreements were cheering. The Supreme Court had handed down its decision in Circuit City Stores, Inc. v. Adams, and it appeared, at least for a while, that employers could keep employment disputes out of court if they so desired.
In short, the Circuit City decision permitted employers to direct all employment disputes, including employment discrimination and harassment claims, to arbitration by way of pre-dispute arbitration agreements. Generally speaking, an employer could require that all employees sign such agreements and force employees to forgo any court case they may file in favor of arbitration. Even though such an arbitration must allow the employee to recover all lost wages, compensatory damages, punitive damages and legal fees the employee could have recovered under applicable federal, state and/or local law, some employers were still interested in forcing employees into arbitration. The main reasons for that