The Supreme Court recently dealt a potential blow to the
FTC's enforcement tool chest. In particular, the
decision impacts its ability to seek monetary relief under a theory
it has used in a wide variety of cases, included privacy and
security ones, that monetary relief constitutes a “permanent
injunction” on consumers' behalf. In AMG Capital Management, LLC v. Federal Trade
Commission, the Supreme Court held that while the FTC should be
able to obtain injunctive relief to stop unfair practices, that
power does not extend to seeking monetary relief for injured
consumers.
The dispute in front of the Supreme Court involved the
interpretation of Section 13(b) of the FTC Act, which allows the
Commission to seek “permanent injunctions.”
Historically, the FTC interpreted that provision to also allow it
to seek monetary remedies to return money to injured consumers. The
Supreme Court disagreed. At issue in the AMG case were allegations
of deceptive payday lending (unfair