In an encouraging development for data breach defendants, the
Superior Court of Pennsylvania recently affirmed a trial court
decision rejecting class certification in a suit filed against two
Medicare programs for losing a flash drive containing personal
information of 286,000 subscribers. The appellate court found
that since the Philadelphia Court of Common Pleas "carefully
considered the numerosity, typicality, adequacy of representation,
and fair and efficient method of adjudication requirements for
class certification," it had not abused its discretion by
denying class certification in March 2015. More broadly, the
decision (Baum v. Keystone Mercy Health Plan, et al., No.
1250 EDA 2015 (Pa. Super. April 26, 2016)) indicates a resistance
to permitting class claims to move forward where members have not
suffered an ascertainable loss and where individual issues
predominate, which may be the case in many data breach suits.