This week, the Ninth Circuit approves a district court decision
to decline supplemental jurisdiction in a joint California Unruh
Civil Rights Act and Americans with Disabilities Act case.
The Court holds that a district court properly declined to
exercise supplemental jurisdiction over a California Unruh Civil
Rights Act claim in a joint Unruh/Americans with Disabilities Act
case.
The Panel: Judges Smith, Jr., Bade, and
VanDyke, with Judge VanDyke writing the opinion, and Judge Bade
writing a partial concurrence and partial dissent.
Key Highlight: “The district
court's order declining supplemental jurisdiction was issued
weeks before it ruled on the ADA claim, the court explained why the
concerns surrounding ADA/Unruh claims applied to the case before
it, and the court explicitly considered the relevant factors when
it invoked [28 U.S.C.] § 1367(c)(4). That is all
that our caselaw requires.”