(January 2020) - In Florida, unlike
parties to a claim, nonparties have no duty to preserve evidence
based on knowledge or foreseeability of litigation. In a recent
opinion, a Florida Court of Appeals was asked to examine whether
the courts should recognize a common law duty for nonparty
preservation of evidence based on the knowledge or foreseeability
of litigation. The Court in Shamrock-Shamrock, Inc. v.
Remark, 271 So.3d 1200 (Fla. 5th DCA 2019) clarified that
nonparties have no duty to preserve evidence based solely on
knowledge or foreseeability of litigation.
In Shamrock-Shamrock,, the Court acknowledged that
Florida does not recognize a separate cause of action for the
spoliation of evidence in the instance that the alleged spoliator
and the defendant in the underlying litigation are one and the
same. However, Florida courts have held that an independent cause
of action for spoliation of evidence against nonparties can accrue
when a nonparty loses, misplaces,