On June 30, 2020, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third
Circuit held in B.L. v. Mahanoy Area School District, No.
19-18421, that a high school student's
off-campus speech was protected by the First Amendment to the same
extent an adult's would be. The Third Circuit affirmed in a
precedential opinion expressly holding for the first time that
off-campus student speech was protected to the full extent afforded
by the First Amendment and not subject to the well-known
Tinker standard that applies to student speech in
school.
BACKGROUND
Appellee B.L. failed to make her high school's varsity
cheerleading team and, over a weekend and away from school, using
her own smartphone, shared a picture of herself at a local
store with a caption including the words "fuck cheer" via
Snapchat. The cheerleading coaches learned about the image and
decided B.L.'s snap violated team and school rules, which B.L.
had acknowledged before joining the team. Those rules