There Is Such A Thing As Too Many Questions: Individualized Inquiries Doom Class Certification

A recent case from the Eastern District of California emphasizes the importance of employers having facially neutral and lawful wage-and-hour policies – as such policies can help in defeating class certification. In Tavares, et al. v. Cargill, Inc., et al., the Plaintiff sought certification of a Rule 23 class consisting of all hourly and non-exempt employees who worked at the Defendants' Fresno, California meat-processing facility. That proposed class included about 4,000 employees, most of whom were production employees.

Plaintiff claimed, among other things, that those employees had not been properly compensated for minimum wage and overtime, largely due to purportedly having to perform tasks before and after clocking into the timekeeping system for which they were not paid. Those tasks included donning/doffing, pre-shift COVID health checks, cleaning lockers, and reading breakroom bulletin boards. Plaintiff claimed the Defendants had a uniform policy of