Last month, the Second Circuit—for the third time, no
less—struck down a class arbitration waiver in American
Express' card acceptance agreement with merchants. The latest
decision, however, is particularly striking given that it follows,
and vigorously distinguishes, the Supreme Court's opinion last
spring in AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion. Will
the Supreme Court, whose previous opinions on the subject have
twice caused the Second Circuit to revisit its original decision,
take this opportunity to weigh in yet again on class arbitration?
If not, how do businesses—and courts--navigate the two
decisions?
Unlike Concepcion, which involved fraud and false
advertising claims under California law, In re American Express Merchants'
Litigation is a federal antitrust case. The plaintiffs
allege that American Express' requirement that merchants honor
all American Express cards—both charge cards and credit
cards—constitutes a tying arrangement in violation of the
Sherman Act.