In Doermer v. Oxford Fin'l Group, Ltd.,
No. 17-1659 (7th Cir. Mar. 7, 2018), the Seventh Circuit had
before it an example of what Chief Judge Diane Wood called a
"depressingly common" type of litigation: "[f]amily
disputes over who owns what." In resolving the appeal, the
court resolved a couple of interesting diversity jurisdictional
issues that such disputes can present.
Brother Richard and sister Kathryn don't get along. Richard
previously sued Kathryn over control of a family foundation, but
the case was dismissed because Richard lacked capacity under
Indiana law to bring a derivative action; the Seventh Circuit
affirmed in Doermer v. Callen, 847 F.3d 522 (7th Cir.
2017).
This time Richard sued Kathryn's financial advisor for
allegedly giving her negligent advice that caused her to mismanage
a family trust, of which they are the two beneficiaries, as well as
two of the three trustees. Richard, a citizen of Illinois, sued the
advisor in state court in that