Who owns the "church?" For most, this is an odd
question. As children, many of us folded our hands and repeated a
rhyme: "Here is the church. Here is the steeple. Open the
doors and see the people." Nevertheless, for well over a
century now courts have been asked to determine who owns the
property of a church in various contexts, including theological
controversies; disputes about assets; and disagreements with
pastors, deacons and members. In the seminal case on church
property disputes, Watson v. Jones, 80 U.S. (13 Wall.)
679, 20 L. Ed. 666 (1871), the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the
lower court lacked subject matter jurisdiction to decide whether
the pro-slavery or anti-slavery faction of Walnut Street
Presbyterian Church in Louisville, Kentucky "owned" the
church. Adopting a "hierarchical deference" approach, the
court decided that the highest ecclesiastical judicatory of the
church should have the final word in the matter.