Circuit Courts Appear To Differ Regarding Constitutional Challenges To The NLRB

Following a multi-million-dollar ruling against it by the National Labor Relations Board ("NLRB"), nursing home operator Care One, LLC, is now challenging the authority of NLRB-appointed Administrative Law Judges ("ALJs") on constitutional grounds before the Second Circuit Court of Appeals. The Second Circuit's line of questioning during the November 12, 2024, oral argument revealed the Court's apparent skepticism towards Care One's challenges, creating the prospect of a circuit court split on key issues that are likely to make their way to the Supreme Court. Care One's arguments follow the trend over the past several years of employers increasingly questioning the authority of ALJs to adjudicate their labor and employment claims before administrative agencies.