ATS Applies to Alleged Child Slavery in the Ivory Coast
Supported by Decisions Made in the US
Doe v. Nestle, S.A., US Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit, October 30, 2018
The plaintiffs allege they were child slaves forced to harvest
cocoa for the defendants in the Ivory coast, and brought suit under
the ATS. The defendants moved to dismiss the complaint on grounds
that it required an impermissibly extraterritorial application of
the statute.
The Court of Appeals acknowledged that the ATS could only apply
to US domestic activities, and resolved an unsettled question by
concluding that the geographic scope of a claim must be viewed in
relation to the “focus” of the statute—leaving
the ATS to apply to “conduct of the defendant which is
alleged by plaintiff to be either a direct violation of the law of
nations or ... constitutes aiding and abetting another’s
violation of the law of nations.” As relevant here, the Court
of Appeals found this test satisfied by