One court giveth and another court taketh away. In the case of
two competing
relators, the First Circuit held that a relator asserting the
first-to-file bar must show not only that his or her complaint
was earlier-filed but also "contained 'all of the
essential facts'"—including the "actual
mechanism"—of the alleged fraud. In so holding, the
First Circuit has turned the "essential facts" test into
something more akin to an "identical facts" test, which
numerous courts, including the First Circuit, had previously
rejected.
United States ex rel. McGuire v . Millennium Laboratories,
Inc. arose out of the government's successful intervention
in several
qui tam suits against Millennium Laboratories.
See No. 17-1106, 2019 WL 1987249, at *1 (1st Cir. 2019).
Specifically, the government alleged that Millennium engaged in two
connecting schemes: "(1) Millennium's submission of claims
for excessive and unnecessary urine drug testing ordered by
physicians through