Authored by Babak Akhlaghi on June 3, 2026. When I read Magnolia Medical Technologies v. Kurin decision my first reaction was simple: I was delighted.
The Patent Office just told a well-funded company: you don’t get a second bite at the apple. You lost in court. You don’t get to relitigate the case before the Patent Office. That’s the holding. And if you own a patent, it matters to you.
What Just Happened
A company called Magnolia Medical had challenged a competitor’s patent in federal court. Their expert got thrown out because they failed to properly support their own arguments. That was their mistake. Their own procedural failure.
After losing, they came to the Patent Office and said: since our expert was excluded, no one ever actually ruled on the technical merits of our challenge. Give us another shot.