In United States v Arthrex, the Supreme Court held that
35 U.S.C. §6(c), which sets forth the authority of Patent
Trial & Appeal Board ("PTAB") Administrative Patent
Judges ("APJs"), is unconstitutional because APJs
effectively wield the power of principal officers (who require
Senate confirmation) while being appointed as inferior officers
(who do not require Senate confirmation) (see our prior blog
here).
The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has begun charting its path
forward for devising and implementing agency rules in response to
the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in
United States v. Arthrex.
To resolve the inconsistency, the Supreme Court vested the USPTO
Director, who is a principal officer, with authority and discretion
to grant rehearing of PTAB Final Written Decisions (FWDs) regarding
patentability of challenged patent claims. The Supreme Court held,
"What matters is that the Director have the discretion to
review decisions rendered by APJs. In this