Imitation, they say, is the sincerest form of flattery. But in
the trademark world, imitation is sincerely unwelcome.
And if a business found to have been competing unfairly by
mimicking a mark persists in making minor tweaks to that mark,
again to edge nearer to a competitor, courts don't flatter.
They penalize.
So operates the so-called safe distance rule, which readers
familiar with this column will recall my having discussed last fall in the context of a
dispute between Innovation Ventures, owner of the 5-Hour Energy
mark, and imitator N2G, which sought to market the 6-Hour Energy
Shot.
The safe-distance rule vests broad discretion in a court to
ensure that the Lanham Act is not frustrated by manufacturers who
seek to circumvent injunctions with subsequent modifications. The
rule permits courts to issue injunctions that sweep even more
broadly than the Lanham Act would otherwise permit against a
manufacturer who has not already been found liable for