Introduction
The late Chief Judge Giles S. Rich, in an oft-quoted
précis of U.S. patent law, remarked that "the name of
the game is the claim." Giles S. Rich, "The Extent of the
Protection and Interpretation of Claims — American
Perspectives," 21 Int'l Rev. Indus. Prop. &
Copyright L., 497, 499 (1990). The U.S. Court of Appeals for
the Federal Circuit's recent decision in Medtronic
CoreValve, LLC v. Edwards Lifesciences Corp.
(CoreValve) serves as a reminder that the claims
at the beginning of a patent can be just as important as those at
the end.
In CoreValve, the Federal Circuit affirmed an invalidity
determination, declined to adopt a proposed "reasonable
person" test for interpreting the sufficiency of a priority
claim, and reiterated that the burden of properly claiming priority
rests squarely on the patentee. CoreValve, No. 2013-1117, slip op.
at 12-13 (Fed. Cir. Jan. 22, 2014).