Samsung Electronics America, Inc. v. Prisua Engineering
Corp., No. 19-1169, Courtroom 203
During Inter Partes Review (IPR) proceedings before the
Patent Trial and Appeal Board, Prisua, the owner of U.S. Patent No.
8,650,591, argued that under IPXL Holdings, LLC v. Amazon.com,
Inc., 430 F.3d 1377 (Fed. Cir. 2005), the Board could not
apply prior art to claims that are allegedly indefinite as directed
to both an apparatus and a method of using the apparatus, and that
the Board does not have the statutory authority to cancel claims
for indefiniteness in IPR proceedings. Samsung, the challenger,
argued that the Board can apply prior art to claims, even when
those claims are indefinite. In its decision, the Board found the
claims to be indefinite under IPXL, so found
Samsung's burden to present a definite claim construction to
prove invalidity not satisfied. The Board therefore declined to
decide whether prior art can be applied to the claims. The Board
also declined to