Co – authored by Amana Abdulwakeel*
University of Florida Research Foundation, Inc. v. General
Electric Co., No. 18-1284, Courtroom 201
The University of Florida Research Foundation (UFRF) appeals
from a Northern District of Florida decision granting GE's
motion to dismiss after finding that the claims of U.S. Patent No.
7,062,251 ("the '251 patent") were directed to a
patent ineligible abstract idea. On appeal, UFRF argues that
the district court lacked jurisdiction to invalidate the '251
patent because UFRF enjoys sovereign immunity as an arm of the
State of Florida, and thus a private party cannot seek to
extinguish the State's property rights in the '251 patent
absent a waiver of immunity. UFRF further argues that filing
an infringement suit constitutes a waiver only as to compulsory
counterclaims, not affirmative defenses. GE argues that
waiver prevents a state from selectively using its immunity to gain
a litigation advantage. Thus, GE argues that any