Discovery Order, Richtek Technology Corp.
v.. uPI Semiconductor Corp., et al., Case No.
09-cv-05659-WHA (Magistrate Judge Laurel Beeler)
Here is a riddle for you: when can an interest in reducing cost
and burden justify broader discovery? The answer: when
documents previously produced in a related case are at
issue. That's what Magistrate Judge Beeler concluded in
Richtek Technology Corp. v. uPI Semiconductor
Corp., in ruling that documents produced
in an ITC investigation would be treated as if produced in the
district court patent case, while simultaneously rejecting
defendant uPI's request to carve out trade secret discovery and
discovery about non-accused products.
Fundamentally, Magistrate Judge Beeler found that uPI's
proposed process to carve out certain documents would be too
burdensome on both the parties and the court, and thus contrary to
the principal of proportionality in FRCP 26. uPI proposed that the
parties exchange lists of what they deemed